Which Juicer should I get? Masticating vs Centrifugal vs Citrus Press

As home juicing begins to get more popular, a central question remains: which juicer should I get? With the huge variety and variation between the different types: centrifugal or masticating, vertical or horizontal, fast or slow; the options to choose from can be mind-boggling – and we haven’t even mentioned citrus presses or smoothie makers!

As the health benefits of juicing continue to take centre stage in our quest for a better more balanced lifestyle, the question of what type of juicer to get becomes more relevant. Here we distill the features of the two main types of juicers – masticating and centrifugal and compare them briefly.

Centrifugal Juicers

Centrifugal juicers work in a style similar to a very fine grater. Pieces of fruit are pushed towards a spinning grating plate with a very fine mesh. The combination of the grating and spinning action extracts the liquid from the fruits and channels it to a spigot tube where a cup is placed. The used pulp is then collected in a chamber within the machine itself.

Cuisinart Juice Extractor

This is the better known type of juicer, typically cheaper and more widely available. Perfect for harder fruits and vegetables these centrifugal juicers tend to be louder and work faster, thereby generating more heat. It is this heat that is supposedly less ideal and that may cause the denaturation of the vitamins within fruits. However, if you’re keen for a quick fresh juice in the morning with minimal work, then these juicers will do the trick.

Click here for our recommended list of the Best Centrifugal Juicers

Masticating Juicers

Masticating juicers, also known as Slow Juicers, are the new breed of juicers that work by ‘wringing’ the pulp of the fruit and vegetables in order to extract the juice. Based on a cork-screw shaped masticator, called the auger, the machine presses the fruits against a mesh in relatively slow revolutions in order to reduce the amount of heat generated.

Omega J8004 Nutrition Center Commercial Masticating Juicer White

Particularly good at extracting juice from leaves and other soft fruit, and milk from nuts, the masticating juicer outputs the juice through a tube, similar to that of the centrifugal juicer, while the processed pulp is churned out externally.

Generally more expensive than the centrifugal juicer, the masticating juicer tends to be the juicer of choice for those seeking to maximise the health benefits of juicing. Traditional these were designed to work horizontally with the auger pressing the fruit in a horizontal manner, however the newer versions are now similar to the centrifugal juicers, vertical in processing – thereby allowing for a smaller footprint on the kitchen countertop.

Omega Juicers VRT350X Heavy Duty Dual-Stage Vertical Single Auger Low Speed Juicer

Other functions in a masticating juicer include pasta extruder (make your own spaghetti or tagliatelle, food processor and grinder.

Click here for our recommended list of the Best Masticating Juicers

Citrus Juicers

Not to be left out, are the specialist citrus juicers, purpose-made for extracting juice from oranges, grapefruits, lemons, limes and other citrus fruits. These devices range from the large electric versions to the single hand-held devices.

KRUPS ZX7000 Stainless Steel Electric Citrus Press b

Check out the options in our Recommended Best Citrus Juicers list.

Which Juicer Are You?

So if you’re in the market for a new juicer, these are some of the things to think about: